Sunday, September 21, 2008

Don't Be Stupid about Punctuation Idiot!

I took up real issue with chapter 3. Normally I can agree to disagree with what I read, however, this is something totally different.

One of the issues I had was that Dora mostly had trouble with periods and commas. Yes, it is important to talk about such issues because people add commas to sentences that are not supposed to be there! But there are other problems, especially for middle and high school students that need to be addressed. The issues perhaps are not as pressing as commas or periods which lead to run-on sentences but, the use of semi-colons or dashes need to be addressed at a higher level of education before college. By the time a student leaves for college, they should know the basics of grammar and punctuation for that matter- not needing to be explained how to use a comma in a sentence. Okay, I need to step down from the soap box for a moment…

Under the heading of Characteristics of Today’s Punctuation, the different forms of writing styles were introduced that include: informal, formal, and narrative. It is interesting because once the style of writing is learned, rarely do rules matter. Some of the ‘best’ writing does not contain correct grammar or punctuation use. As the audience, whether we know it was intentional or not, perhaps we will never know but, does that matter- the use of correct grammar. Who is to say what correct grammar is?

But back to the beginning about Dora (see, fragment perhaps, but it works). Teaching a younger students about commas is and will be different than teaching a high school student about grammar. It is hard to say, but I hope that students will know or understand what a comma is by the time they reach high school. Perhaps I am hoping too much- my dreams might be crushed. I think that the overall lesson about punctuation is that it can and will change the context of a sentence, and students need to know that (period, dot).

No comments: