Grammar and mechanics are a struggle for high school students around the nation, it is not going away either. The first question that pops into my mind is why is it such a struggle? We start writing when we are in elementary school, perhaps there is not an answer to that question. I have one guess to this and I believe that it is a vicious cycle that we as teachers are going to need to break. Students dislike reading which enhances the student’s ability with writing, but if the student struggles with reading or writing that student will struggle with the other, therefore, will not want to do both.
Although it is important to weave grammar into a daily routine in the classroom, I cannot help but wonder if that is reality. To grab the attention of the students when they come into the door the teacher can have an opening activity that the students will conduct within the first 5 minutes of class, but at times it might not be possible to go into a full-on discussion about grammar. How often should an English teacher prepare a lesson about grammar, furthermore, what is the reality of how many grammatical lessons can be built into the classroom?
Some of the concepts developed that were described in Mechanically Inclined are interesting to consider for a classroom. Out of all of the concepts, Mentor Texts: The Close- Up Lens of a Sentence grabbed my attention. Although students will complain about doing a task such as this, if a student can break down a sentence and understand, more importantly, explain what is wrong with the sentence and how to fix it, they are fully developing grammatical skills. If a daily discussion about grammar is not possible, the next best step could be a weekly. The students could find sentences or anything that is grammatically incorrect; bring it to class on chosen day of the week to discuss what is incorrect and how to fix it. Break it down.
Break it down. Explain. Fix.
Sunday, August 31, 2008
Tuesday, August 26, 2008
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)